Baldrige National Quality Program links to Homepage. National Institute of Standards and Technology logo links to NIST Homepage. Quality artwork in banner.
skip navigation
Homepage link Award Recipients link Baldrige Process link Materials Available link Search link Site Map link Bottom section of banner no links.
Assessment of Leadership Cover that links to the PDF file.

Overview of the Award Process Review Cycle

PDF Version

Description

Following the receipt of the Award applications, the first step of the Award process review cycle begins with the Independent Review, in which members of the Board of Examiners are assigned to each of the applications. Each application is evaluated independently by Examiners, who write observations relating to the Scoring System.

All applicants are then sent through a Consensus Review. A team of Examiners, led by a Senior Examiner, conducts a series of reviews, first managed virtually through a secure Web site and eventually concluded through a focused conference call. The purpose of this series of reviews is for the team to reach consensus on comments and scores that capture the team’s collective view of the applicant’s strengths and opportunities for improvement based on the inputs from the Independent Review.

After the Consensus Review process, the Panel of Judges selects applicants to receive site visits based upon the scoring profiles. If an applicant is not selected for Site Visit Review, one of the Examiners on the Consensus Team edits the final consensus report, which becomes the feedback report. Site visits are conducted for the highest-scoring applicants to clarify any uncertainty or confusion the Examiners may have regarding the written application and to verify that the information in the application is correct.

After the site visit is completed, the team of Examiners prepares a final site visit scorebook. Applications, consensus scorebooks, and site visit scorebooks for all applicants receiving site visits are forwarded to the Panel of Judges. The Judges make final recommendations on which applicants should receive the Award. Following the Judges’ review and recommendations of Award recipients, the Site Visit Team Leader edits the final site visit scorebook, which becomes the feedback report.



You need to have Acrobat Reader installed on your computer to view the PDF file. If you do not have Acrobat Reader installed on your computer, click on the Acrobat icon below and download the program. People with visual disabilities can download tools and information at http://access.adobe.com to help make Adobe PDF files accessible.

Click here to link to the Adobe web site to download Acrobat to be able to view PDF files.




BNQP Website comments:
nqp@nist.gov

Date created: 5/05/2008
Last updated: 5/05/2008

search CSTL contact CSTL CSTL products and services CSTL Research Areas go to CSTL home page